Open Hours
Wed - Thu
3:00pm - 10:00PM
Fri
3:00pm - 11:00PM
Sat
1:00pm - 11:00PM
Sun
1:00pm - 9:00PM
6616 Superior Avenue
Sarasota, Florida 34231
HEADER

Sarasota’s Best
Handcrafted Artisan
Ice Cream & ITALIAN ICES

WE MAKE ALL OF OUR ICE CREAM
ON SITE RIGHT HERE IN SARASOTA

 

Home

HANDCRAFTED ARTISAN

ICE CREAM

NO Artificial Flavors
NO Artificial Colors
NO Preservatives
Just real ingredients
NO Sugar Free

Best handcrafted artisan ice cream in Sarasota with a creamy consistency and a delicious rich texture. All of Pete’s ice cream is made on site. We use original and real ingredients to make our ice cream (Candy bars, Herbs, Coffee, Cereals & Fruits ), and add all ingredients during the process of making the ice cream, not after. We also have boozy ice cream!

We Use Natural colors in our ice cream that our derived from

Red …..Red Beets Green…..Kale Yellow…..Turmeric

Blue…..Blue Spirulina Purple…..Purple Carrots

No you don’t taste the colors you just get the color

Sorry NO Sugar Free

Current Flavors


{ Flavors Rotate}
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mint
Salted Caramel Pecan
Pistachio
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Almond Joy
Pumpkin Spice
Coffee
Eggnog
Candy Cane
Christmas Tree Cakes
Flavors Updated on 12/12/25
 
 

Boozy Ice Creams


{ Must be 21+}
(21+)
Siesta Key Coffee Rum
Boozy flavors are infused with Alcohol

Pints


{ Flavors Rotate }
Vanilla
Chocolate
Mint Chip
Pumpkin Snap
Butter Pecan
Salted Caramel Pecan
Oreo Cookie
Black Raspberry Chip
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Banana Cookie Dough
Apple Pie A La Mode
Siesta Sands
Eggnog
Pistachio
Lavender Honey
Tiramisu
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Almond Joy
Vanilla
Coffee
Christmas Tree Cakes
Mint
Flavors Updated on 12/12/25

Frappes, Root Beer, Floats & Malts


Ice Cream Sandwiches


ITALIAN ICE

Current Flavors


* = REAL FRUIT
* Lemon
* Blueberry
Pumpkin Spice
Iced Coffee
Grape
Swedish Fish
Peach
Root Beer
Watermelon
Cotton Candy
Flavors Updated on 12/12/25
 

Slush – Water Ice

Leave us a Review

 

Suggest a flavor

Contact Us today, we’d love to hear from you