Order OnlineHome
HANDCRAFTED ARTISAN
ICE CREAM
Best handcrafted artisan ice cream in Sarasota with a creamy consistency and a delicious rich texture. All of Pete’s ice cream is made on site. We use original and real ingredients to make our ice cream (Candy bars, Herbs, Coffee, Cereals & Fruits ), and add all ingredients during the process of making the ice cream, not after. We also have boozy ice cream!
We Use Natural colors in our ice cream that our derived from
Red …..Red Beets Green…..Kale Yellow…..Turmeric
Blue…..Blue Spirulina Purple…..Purple Carrots
No you don’t taste the colors you just get the color
Sorry NO Sugar Free
Current Flavors
Boozy Ice Creams
Non Dairy – Oat Milk Based
Pints
Frappes, Root Beer, Floats & Malts
In New England, milkshakes never include ice cream. Adding ice cream makes it a “frappe” drink.
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Nuguts
updated : 4/1/26
ITALIAN ICE
Current Flavors
Slush – Water Ice- sorbet
Pete’s Italian ice is a smooth frozen-dessert option with rotating flavors. Recipes, ingredients, toppings, and preparation conditions can change.
Check the current menu for availability and call Pete before ordering when an allergy, intolerance, celiac disease, or dietary requirement matters.
Read ingredient and allergen guidance.
Come taste why we say it’s more than just a snack—it’s a mood. 🍧✨
Italian Ice vs. sorbet Both use water, sugar, and fruit purée. However, sorbet often incorporates stabilizers for smoothness, while Italian ice generally does not Italian ice is more refreshing
Italian Ice offers that “creamy” feel without the dairy—that’s a huge selling point for the health-conscious crowd!
